View all newsletters
Receive our newsletter - data, insights and analysis delivered to you
  1. Technology
September 24, 2010updated 19 Aug 2016 10:05am

BMW tries its hand at British mod with new Mini Scooter E, fails

New electric scooter may be modern, but it's not very mod

By

So BMW thinks it can follow in the iconic footsteps of the British mod movement, unveiling a "zero emission" electric scooter at London Fashion Week. Sadly, what they’ve showed off is likely to prove about as popular with ageing mods as a kick in the head with a motorbike boot from a rival rocker. In other words, it may be radical but it sure as hell isn’t going to have any mods ditching their Vespas.

BMW Group designer Adrian Van Hooydonk said the firm had a lot of fun designing the new Mini scooter, which is fair enough. But why the mod looks? "Mini does not have scooter heritage, but England does," he said, and this comes after all from the Mini design team. No scooter heritage? Ain’t that the truth: what BMW unveiled is a poor representation of mod: ‘cod mod’, you might say.

If anything, the mod references are too blatant. There’s the obvious use of the Royal Air Force ‘target’ logo. It will be interesting to see what the RAF thinks of this as it has been known, quite rightly, to get pretty tetchy about the use of its logo. Especially, one would guess, when it’s being used by a company that built military vehicles used in the war! There’s also a Union Jack on the seat: iconic, sure, but also a little ironic?

There’s a fair amount of chrome, which Hooydonk says is a carry-over from the early Mini but also brings to mind the arrays of chrome mirrors that adorned the real mod’s typical scooter,as do the extra blue lights. But that’s about it.

To start the scooter you don’t simply turn a key: you dock your iPhone in an enclosed, transparent docking station and then an icon appears on the phone with a starter button. Using an iPhone to start the thing and then deliver GPS? Not very mod. A bit Teddy Boy, perhaps.

And what about this little box under the handlebars that holds two teacups? You’ve got to be kidding me. Paul Weller types are about as likely to want to carry two teacups on their scoot as they are to ask David Cameron round for a brew (I use the analogy wisely – when Cameron told Radio 4 his favourite record was The Jam’s Eton Rifles, Weller retorted: "Which part of it didn’t he get? It wasn’t intended as a f****** jolly drinking song for the cadet corps.")

Content from our partners
Why enterprises of all sizes must  embrace smart manufacturing solutions
European Technology Leadership: Deutsche Bank CTO Gordon Mackechnie
Print’s role in driving the environmental agenda

The BMW Mini Scooter E

The Mini Scooter E, unveiled at London Fashion Week, with Agyness Deyn.

But there is a more fundamental problem with the Mini Scooter E’s mod credentials. It’s not just electric, it’s also automatic. Sure, even mods move on, but turn up at a mod scooter rally today (yes, they still have them up and down the country) on an automatic scooter – even an automatic Vespa or Lambretta – and everyone will look at you as if you have just stepped off a piece of cheese. Your scooter absolutely must have manual gears if you are to be down with the mods. It should really be two-stroke, which is far more polluting even than more recent four stroke engines, can you believe!

So while the Mini Scooter E may prove popular with youngsters who’ve listened to their dad’s Who, Faces and Jam albums, it’s not likely to prove popular with the real mods: the dads themselves. They’ll turn up on their manual, two-stroke Vespas and Lambrettas until they finally decide to hang up their Parkas.

 

Websites in our network
NEWSLETTER Sign up Tick the boxes of the newsletters you would like to receive. Tech Monitor's research, insight and analysis examines the frontiers of digital transformation to help tech leaders navigate the future. Our Changelog newsletter delivers our best work to your inbox every week.
I consent to New Statesman Media Group collecting my details provided via this form in accordance with the Privacy Policy
SUBSCRIBED

THANK YOU