View all newsletters
Receive our newsletter - data, insights and analysis delivered to you
  1. Technology
July 16, 2010updated 19 Aug 2016 10:05am

UPDATED: Apple must choose between good and evil

So will it recall the faulty iPhone 4?

By Jason Stamper Blog

It’s Google that has the company tagline ‘Don’t be evil’, one which it has found harder and harder to stick to as it’s gone from the underdog to an advertising-driven search behemoth. But it is Apple that is now grappling with the conflict between its profits, or keeping its fervent customers happy.

Since Apple launched the iPhone 4, an apparent fault came to light involving the placement of its antenna. Scores of users complained of experiencing poor reception or reception that cuts in and out intermittently, to which Apple replied with a statement in which it simply argued that people were holding the gadget wrong:

"Gripping any phone will result in some attenuation of its antenna performance with certain places being worse than others depending on the placement of the antennas. This is a fact of life for every wireless phone. If you ever experience this on your Phone 4, avoid gripping it in the lower left corner in a way that covers both sides of the black strip in the metal band, or simply use one of many available cases."

Perhaps not surprisingly, that wasn’t enough to satisfy many of Apple’s customers, and the grumbling on user forums and in the media gathered steam.

Apple iPhone 4G

Apple again responded, this time with a little more detail about a fault with signal strength, but not a lot less arrogance: while admitting it had made a simple mistake in the way the phone displays signal strength, thereby giving false readings to users, it still had the gall to start the letter like so:

Content from our partners
Rethinking cloud: challenging assumptions, learning lessons
DTX Manchester welcomes leading tech talent from across the region and beyond
The hidden complexities of deploying AI in your business

"The iPhone 4 has been the most successful product launch in Apple’s history. It has been judged by reviewers around the world to be the best smart phone ever, and users have told us that they love it. So we were surprised when we read reports of reception problems, and we immediately began investigating them."

That investigation left Apple "stunned" when it discovered it had got its signal strength formula wrong. To fix this, it said it would adopt AT&T’s recommended formula for calculating how many bars to display for a given signal. The fact it was using its own — totally wrong — formula in the first place is just classic Apple: it thought it knew better.

Incredibly, it also said it would be making, "[signal strength] bars 1, 2 and 3 a bit taller so they will be easier to see." In other words, they still couldn’t do anything about the faulty antenna problem, and they couldn’t improve signal strength, but they could sure as hell make very weak signals look that bit more healthy by making the bars bigger. Strike two for evil?

But the complaints about the antenna issue continued to flood in, and the matter came to a head when influential US consumer watchdog Consumer Reports issued a statement on Monday saying that it could no longer recommend the iPhone 4 because of the antenna problem.

Given the huge influence that Consumer Reports has, it seems Apple may now have to act. It’s reported to be holding a press conference later today in which it says it will be discussing the iPhone 4, and presumably the antenna problems. We’ll bring you news as we have it.

Meanwhile analysts believe Apple now has three options open to it regarding the fault: give out free ‘bumper cases’ which keep fingers further from the antenna and seem to alleviate the problem; do a full product recall and fix the fault or simply do nothing.

Giving out the bumper cases will cost it a few million dollars, which is small change to the firm. But it would be an embarrassment to admit that its shiny new gizmo only works effectively clothed in a strip of black silicone. A full recall will cost at least $1bn according to analysts, and even more embarrassment. Yet perhaps it would at least avoid its reputation being tarnished any more than it has already.

Then of course there’s the ‘do nothing’ scenario, which is perhaps the most likely. I’ve been saying for some time that Apple has been becoming increasingly complacent about customer service and fixing product faults, though Apple’s army of loyal fans won’t hear a bad word said about the firm.

Consumers have been left to turn to the courts over faulty MacBook power supplies. A man was alleged to have been offered a full refund on an exploding iPod on condition he sign a confidentiality agreement. Apple’s own user forum has hundreds of complaints about the fact that its third generation Shuffle MP3 player, which is marketed as ideal for people hitting the gym, develops a fault when exposed to even a small amount of sweat.

Most technology companies have occasional issues with product bugs and faults: they’re pushing the boundaries of what’s possible with the latest components, and even rigorous testing prior to release is not foolproof. But it is how companies respond to such faults when they are discovered that should be the barometer of the company’s professionalism, decency and — let’s face it — respect for its own customers.

Whatever Apple announces later today about the iPhone 4, what many have come to realise about the company is what I have been saying for some time: it is really not deserving of this army of Apple fans’ ardent loyalty. Apple would surely still be telling users to hold the device differently or buy their own bumper case if Consumer Reports had not come out to back up disgruntled punters. So what say you: is Apple the new Evil Empire?

[UPDATE: At its press conference at 6pm BST on Friday as we went to press, Apple CEO Steve Jobs announced free cases for any iPhone 4 buyers, and if you already bought a case or bumper case, a refund. Jobs also argued that it isn’t just Apple’s smartphone that suffers from such problems, taking the opportunity to sling a bit of mud at the Blackberry and Samsung phones. In other words, it’s not us, it’s smartphones in general. In which case, why the free cases to reduce the patchy antenna coverage? Meanwhile a recall looks to have been ruled out of the question.]


Websites in our network
Select and enter your corporate email address Tech Monitor's research, insight and analysis examines the frontiers of digital transformation to help tech leaders navigate the future. Our Changelog newsletter delivers our best work to your inbox every week.
  • CIO
  • CTO
  • CISO
  • CSO
  • CFO
  • CDO
  • CEO
  • Architect Founder
  • MD
  • Director
  • Manager
  • Other
Visit our privacy policy for more information about our services, how Progressive Media Investments may use, process and share your personal data, including information on your rights in respect of your personal data and how you can unsubscribe from future marketing communications. Our services are intended for corporate subscribers and you warrant that the email address submitted is your corporate email address.